Ina Garten Brought This Gag Gift to Amy Poehler’s Podcast

This time of year can come with pressure to find the perfect holiday gifts for your loved ones, but The Barefoot Contessa thinks you don’t need to take it so seriously. On a recent episode of the “Good Hang” podcast, Ina Garten showed off her humorous side by presenting a gag gift to Amy Poehler that left Poehler in stitches. Garten’s “Perfect Roast Chicken” is one of her most requested recipes, so it was perfect that she gave Poehler a fake roasted chicken that looked like the real thing.

If you want to follow Garten’s lead with a gag gift, we found several ideas; if you’d like to go more traditional with your host gift or white elephant gift, we found options for that, too. Below, shop dessert-inspired blankets, an editor-favorite wine opener to make serving drinks easier on a party host, and more steal-worthy gifts to give this season.

Shop White Elephant, Gag, and Host Gifts for the Holidays

Gcroet Chicken Roasting Realistic Chicken

While this might not be the exact one Garten presented on Poehler’s podcast, this realistic fake chicken almost looks like it belongs on your dinner table; even its skin is perfectly browned. Best of all? There’s no mess or cleanup involved.

Zwilling Enfinigy Electric Wine Bottle Opener

We would be remiss if we didn’t include the Zwilling Enfinigy electric wine bottle opener on our list. It’s one of our favorites, and it’ll make serving drinks much easier on the host. In our tests, it took just five seconds to uncork bottles, and we love that the clear lower shaft would let party guests watch the uncorking process. To make the gift even more special, pair it with one of our favorite bargain holiday wines.

Bonnie and Pop Chocolate Gift Box

Chocolate gifts are welcomed at nearly any holiday party. This gift box is filled with over a pound of assorted milk, dark, and white chocolates. The pieces are individually wrapped, so they’d even make good gift bag additions if you’re the party’s host.

Smirly Charcuterie Board Set

You can’t go wrong with this charcuterie board set, which has over 18,000 five-star ratings. The charcuterie board has ample room to display snacks and a hidden drawer to store the included cheese knives. Amazon shoppers report that it’s wonderful for serving cheese, fruits, vegetables, meats, and desserts.

Hanolly Store 6-Piece Food Scented Candle Set

This candle set will fill your recipient’s home with the smell of freshly baked goods, all without touching the oven. It comes with six scents: pumpkin pie, gingerbread, chocolate chip cookies, coffee cake, cherry cheesecake, and pecan and pumpkin waffles.

Prank Pack Pudding Pouch Prank Gift Box

Imagine the look on the unsuspecting recipient’s face when they remove the wrapping paper to find this gift box that depicts a pudding storage pouch inside. This prank gift will provide a good laugh for both the recipient and the giftee alike.

Mermaker Cookies Blanket

We’re all about food, so naturally, we were drawn to this blanket that looks like a chocolate chip cookie. To make the gift a bit less of a gag, pair it with a homemade batch of chocolatey cookies to match.

Graza Extra Virgin Olive Oil Variety Pack

Any cook will love to receive this 2-piece Graza Sizzle and Drizzle olive oil variety pack. The Sizzle is a heat-safe cooking oil, while the Drizzle adds a finishing touch to your dish. It’s a Food & Wine favorite olive oil; we love the glass bottle’s spout top and how it balances the taste of dishes without overpowering them.

Kaidouma Funny Grill Aprons

This grill apron keeps the cook’s clothes clean and free from food spills and splatters, while putting a smile on everyone’s face. After all, the home chef deserves recognition for their hard work, no matter how their food turns out.