10 Amazon White Elephant Kitchen Gift Ideas Under $25

The white elephant gift exchange is a lovely and devious game of surprises, and I love every part of it, especially thinking up the best gift idea. Whether it’s the pour-over coffee maker that caused a series of steals or the huge bottle of olive oil no one grabbed because it was hidden in a wine bag, catching people off guard is how I make the game fun. And since I’m so good at it (humbly brushes off shoulders), I thought I’d help you out with your white elephant gift search, too.

Even with a budget of $25, you can easily add excitement to your next holiday party. Amazon has gift options out the wazoo at this price point, so I took the liberty of pulling 10 that can pass for gag gifts but are actually practical, crowd-pleasing white elephant gifts everyone will fight for. The best part is that these picks, including a very colorful knife set, a bagel guillotine, and even a more traditional Yeti mug, are up to 60% off at Amazon.

The Best Amazon White Elephant Gifts Under $25

• Ototo PanCats 3-Piece Egg Ring Set of 3, $15, originally $25
• Marco Almond 12-Piece Kitchen Knife Set, $10, originally $25
• Hoan Bagel Guillotine, $14, originally $28
• Aroma 3-Cup Rice Cooker, $20, originally $25
• Yeti Rambler 14-Ounce Stackable Mug, $21, originally $30

Ototo 3-Piece Egg Cooker Ring Set

When these cat-shaped rings are revealed, no one will believe they’re actually useful kitchen tools. These egg cooker rings keep eggs perfectly round for breakfast sandwiches, sunnyside up or otherwise, and they prevent pancakes from touching each other in small nonstick pans. They’re also just about the cutest kitchen item one could have.

Marco Almond 12-Piece Kitchen Knife Set

They’ll think you bought this rainbow-hued set from a retail store on the way to the party; however, it’s really an Amazon-recommended knife set with over 12,000 five-star reviews. One shopper says the knives “hold their sharpness surprisingly well,” even after a month of daily use. At 60% off, it’s an affordable white elephant gift they’ll keep around.

Misen Silicone Mixing Spoon

This cooking spoon will become one partygoer’s everyday cooking companion. During white elephant, this spoon may be mistaken for toxic black plastic, but its non-toxic silicone build is safe for cooking temperatures up to 450°F and is dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

Hoan Bagel Guillotine

The concept of a bagel slicer is novel until you realize you’ve never actually perfectly halved a bagel with a bread knife. With this bagel guillotine’s razor-sharp blade, whoever claims this gift will get evenly sliced and toasted bagel halves for years to come.

Ovente Electric Kettle

There’s bound to be at least a few people in the gift exchange who are still boiling water on the stovetop or microwaving it for tea, coffee, oatmeal, and more. They’ll definitely vie for this electric kettle, which can boil over six cups of water in minutes and has earned five-star reviews from over 40,000 Amazon shoppers.

Aroma 3-Cup Rice Cooker

Trust me, a rice cooker is a serious game-changer during white elephant. All bets are off when people catch a glimpse of the small appliance they’ve been procrastinating on buying for ages. I’ll even wager that some didn’t realize they could buy one for under $25. I used this affordable Aroma model for years, and it never did me wrong.

Yeti Rambler 14-Ounce Stackable Mug

Yeti consistently tops our tested lists of insulated drinkware, like travel coffee mugs, because its gear keeps drinks, soups, and more hot or cold for hours. Now at its lowest price ever at Amazon, this lowcountry peach Rambler is a commuter’s best friend and won’t take up too much space in the kitchen cabinet. Grab an extra for yourself, while you’re at it.

Scotch-Brite Odor Resist Non-Scratch Scrub Sponges

One of the best white elephant gifts I’ve ever stolen was a gift bag filled with kitchen cleaning supplies. The products lasted me months, and the kitchen sponges were among my favorite items in the bag. These non-scratch sponges make great gifts, as they’re safe on nonstick cookware and various home surfaces.

Lodge Chef Collection 8-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

If you’re trying to give someone a gift that lasts a lifetime, cast iron cookware is where it’s at. With the right care, Lodge’s cast iron is heirloom-quality, and this Chef Collection skillet is designed with a comfortable handle and spatula-friendly slope. Besides, it’s a must-buy at its lowest price ever.

Graza Drizzle Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Graza’s trendsetting, editor-recommended olive oil could be the star of this year’s gift exchange. The Drizzle has a robust flavor for topping salads, pasta dishes, and even ice cream or cake. It’ll be one lucky person’s perfect introduction to exploring the world of olive oils.